Climate Disclosure Leadership Index (CLI) 2007

 Click here to download this index

The Climate Disclosure Leadership Index (CDLI) is produced by report writers Innovest. It is comprised of 68 FT500 companies that show distinction in their responses to the Carbon Disclosure Project survey based on their reporting of greenhouse gas emissions and assessment of a company's climate change strategy

All companies in the FT500 sample were assessed relative to their peers to provide an evaluation for investors, through the CDLI on which companies have developed the most comprehensive climate change disclosure practices. Innovest rank companies on a 100 point scale and all companies which achieved a score of 85 or over are featured in the CDLI.

Climate Disclosure Leadership Index members were distinguished by the disclosure of their awareness of the risks and opportunities of climate change, as well as the quality and effectiveness of programs put in place to reduce overall greenhouse gas emissions.

To demonstrate the relationship between leadership in carbon disclosure and leadership in carbon performance, Innovest's Carbon BetaTM ratings were also introduced into this year's CDLI. Innovest, through a proprietary methodology, calculates the net carbon exposure of a firm, taking into consideration current and potential regulatory frameworks within the different countries in which a corporation operates. The concept also accounts for the different risks, at an industry-specific level, to which companies may be exposed. In addition, the rating model integrates an analysis of risk management capability and strategic profit opportunities. Innovest's Carbon BetaTM ratings range from CCC (worst in class) through AAA (best in class)

HSBC's Climate Disclosure Leadership Index score was incorrectly calculated and reported in the 2007 CDP Report. HSBC achieved a score of 95, not 85. Both versions of the on-line FT500 report now reflect this correction. To minimise the risk of future miscalculations, an external auditor will verify the accuracy of CDLI methodology used by report writers. CDP and report writers Innovest Strategic Value Advisors, apologise for any inconvenience this may have caused.

Dow Chemical originally scored 85 points but were missing from the CDLI table in the printed FT500 Reports, they have been added to the online PDF versions. CDP and report writers Innovest Strategic Value Advisors, apologise for any inconvenience this may have caused.

Carbon-Intensive Sectors

Sector Companies Scope 1 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
Scope 2 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
Total Scope 1,2 and 3 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
CDLI Score Innovest Carbon Beta Rating
Automobiles DaimlerChrysler
Nissan Motor
1,910,221
797,000
5,349,307
1,323,000
7,259,528
150,466,000
90
85
BBB
BBB
Diversified Chemicals Bayer
E I du Pont de Nemours (DuPont)
Dow Chemicals
4,100,000
9,000,000


27,200,000
3,900,000
3,100,000


10,500,000
8,000,000
12,100,000


37,700,000
95
95


85
A
AAA


AA
Electric Power Companies N. Exelon
Entergy Corp
12,100,000
28,350,587
900,000
773,114
13,000,000
29,123,701
95
90
AA
A
Electric Utilities - International Iberdrola
Fortum
Scottish & Southern Energy
21,964,784
11,000,000
25,880,000
3,475,029
178,000
16,687
25,482,138
13,829,600
25,930,396
100
95
90
AAA
AAA
AAA
Gas Utilities Gaz de France 5,578,946 127,328 6,325,259 95 AA
Household Durables Matsushita Electric 1,042,121 3,083,766 4,125,887 90 AAA
Integrated Oil & Gas BP
Repsol YPF
Total
ENI
Exxon Mobil
Petrobras
Suncor Energy
59,300,000
26,492,885
57,800,000
59,300,000
145,500,000
49,860,000
11,030,033
10,100,000
1,545,939

3,750,000
13,300,000
571,960
315,741
608,400,000
28,718,824
686,800,000
63,050,000
158,800,000
50,431,960
11,345,774
90
90
90
85
85
85
85
AAA
A
AA
A
BB
BB
BBB
Metals & Mining Rio Tinto
BHP Billiton
Alcan
Alcoa
15,300,000
23,200,000
20,300,000
33,900,000
13,500,000
28,600,000
11,600,000
26,200,000
654,336,000
51,928,500
31,900,000
60,100,000
100
90
85
85
AAA
AA
AAA
AAA
Multi-Utilities & Unregulated Power Suez
Centrica
Veolia Environnement
83,421,727
8,775,035
36,482,620

137,251
3,025,415
83,421,727
8,912,286
39,674,035
90
85
85
AA
AAA
A
Oil & Gas Exploration & Production Woodside Petroleum 8,273,583 14,720 8,288,303 85 BB
Pharmaceuticals Pfizer 1,223,876 1,184,441 2,639,317 85 A
Steel Sumitomo Metal Inds. 21,810,000 4,470,000 26,280,000 85 AA




Low-Carbon Sectors

Sector Companies Scope 1 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
Scope 2 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
Total Scope 1,2 and 3 Emissions
Reported in CDP5
Tonnes CO2e)
CDLI Score Innovest Carbon Beta Rating
Banks Europe HBOS
Unicredit Group
47946
119,330
16,767
646,836
80,815
850,632
95
85
AAA
AAA
Banks Japan & Australia Westpac Banking
ANZ Banking
102,942

12,746
5,273

171,729
116,102

197,069
100

90
AAA

AA
Banks North America Royal Bank of Canada
CIBC
8,554

10,312
54,784

37,379
95,995

70,098
90

85
AAA

AAA
Beverages & Tobacco British American Tobacco
Coca Cola
Diageo
365,550


1,962,287
505,157
376,712


2,905,492
243,521
3,109,797


4,922,779
2,253,678
95


95
90
A


AA
AA
Communications Equipment Ericsson 8,000 145,000 690,025 90 AAA
Computers & Peripherals Hewlett-Packard
EMC
Dell
IBM
Sun Microsystems
134,500

30,893
7,000
533,064
13,804
1,464,000

256,324
377,000
2,291,297
241,128
2,062,300

287,217
384,000
2,824,361
254,932
100

95
90
90
85
AAA

B
AAA
AAA
BBB
Food & Drug Retailing Tesco 1,726,650 2,346,380 4,106,958 90 AAA
Food Products Unilever
Cadbury Schweppes
1,581,565
458,276
1,711,317
551,153
173,792,882
5,725,031
90
85
AAA
AAA
Global Banks HSBC
Citigroup
Royal Bank of Scotland
ABN Amro Holding
Standard Chartered
UBS
Barclays

ING
Societe Generale
0
48,507
96,799

0

1,397

31,519
36,737

113,708
27,829
634,000
1,338,905
389,242

336,514

128,479

230,015
370,004

227,555
128,479
813,000
22,882,483
556,041

414,720

139,927

293,158
473,201

341,263
223,948
95
95
95

90

90

90
85

85
85
AAA
AA
BBB

AAA

AA

AAA
AA

AAA
A
Health Care Equipment & Supplies Baxter International 245,000 486,000 884,700 90 AAA
Life & Health Insurance Legal & General Group 0 10,359 15,344 90 BBB
Multi-Line Insurance & Brokerage Allianz
Aviva
55,854
30,437
418,588
39,439
630,457
126,269
90
85
AA
AAA
Reinsurance Swiss Re 8,158 59,157 95,895 85 AAA
Integrated Telecommunication Services Deutsche Telekom
BCE
BT Group
Telstra
353,955

114,463
253,547
149,075
2,828,777

187,615
467,381
1,031,576
3,182,732

318,179
779,617
1,360,574
95

90
85
85
AAA

AA
A
B
Multiline Retail Marks & Spencer
Wal Mart Stores
66,000

4,306,369
212,000

14,413,425
5,584,000

20,388,574
90

85
AAA

A
Real Estate Management & Development Land Securities 76,347 162,741 479,023 85 AAA
Software & IT Services Microsoft 14,730 137,870 416,170 90 BBB